How is this different from plantar fasciitis?
They are frequently confused but quite different. Plantar fasciitis is a mechanical heel problem – sharp first-step pain under the heel in the morning. Tarsal tunnel syndrome is a nerve problem – burning, tingling and numbness in the sole, often worse with activity and at night, with a tingling shock when the nerve behind the ankle is tapped. Because the treatments are entirely different, distinguishing them is essential, and it is one of the first things we sort out.
Why do I need a scan?
Because tarsal tunnel syndrome is one nerve entrapment where imaging genuinely earns its place. A meaningful proportion of cases are caused by something taking up space in the tunnel – a ganglion cyst, a varicose vein, a swollen tendon or a bony spur – and these are often directly treatable. An MRI or ultrasound looks for exactly that. Finding a structural cause can transform the outlook, which is why we do not just guess here.
Can it be treated without surgery?
Often, yes – especially when it is idiopathic or driven by flat feet and overpronation. Orthotics to support the foot, activity modification, nerve-gliding, manual therapy and foot-focused Ayurveda therapies help many people. Where there is a specific structural cause, treating that cause is what resolves it. Surgery is reserved for a defined structural lesion or genuinely refractory cases.
My flat feet – are they causing this?
They can be. A flat, overpronating foot stretches and loads the posterior tibial nerve at the ankle, and correcting that mechanics with supportive footwear or orthotics is a key part of treatment for those cases. Addressing the foot posture often settles the nerve symptoms without anything more invasive.
Could it be diabetic nerve damage instead?
It is an important distinction. Diabetic and other peripheral neuropathies usually affect both feet symmetrically in a stocking-like pattern, whereas tarsal tunnel syndrome is typically one foot with a clear focal point behind the ankle. We screen for neuropathy, because if that is the real cause, the management is quite different – controlling the diabetes and treating the nerve pain, not releasing a tunnel.
When is surgery indicated?
When imaging shows a specific structural cause within the tunnel (like a ganglion) that needs removing, or when significant compression persists despite proper conservative care. Surgery (tarsal tunnel release) works best when there is a clear lesion to address; for idiopathic cases it is less predictable, which is why we image carefully, treat the cause where there is one, and try conservative care first for the rest.